Book Keeping: A Reader's Community

Reading Group Guide: Witches of America

Witches of America by Alex Mar

When the documentary filmmaker Alex Mar set out to report on the nearly one million Americans who practice Paganism today, she found herself drawn into a world that defies stereotype. Witches of America retraces Mar’s five-year trip into the occult, which takes her from Paganism’s American mecca in the San Francisco Bay Area, to a gathering of more than a thousand witches in the Illinois woods, to the New Orleans branch of one of the world’s most influential magical societies. As she introduces us to the array of women and men who seek a variety of experiences through rites both ancient and new, a unique community emerges—one that provokes us to examine the very nature of faith.

Illuminating the shadowed world of witchcraft, Witches of America speaks powerfully to the mysteries of the spirit. We hope the following guide will enhance your discussion of this extraordinary journey.

Witches of America
Barnes and Noble

Questions and Topics for Discussion

1. Discuss your own experiences with spirituality. How do the rituals described in the book compare with the religious traditions you observed as a child?

2. Victor and Cora’s magical descendants will have to “pass on the Feri current,” although revisions and regeneration are encouraged. How do the communities described in the book create hierarchies and leaders while remaining open to change?

3. While many religions restrict sexual behavior, considering it a path to sin, the author confronts the belief that sex can have magical and spiritual power. Did the book change the way you view sexuality?

4. As we see at Stone City, in the woods of Illinois, and through several outdoor rituals and initiations, the natural world plays an important role in Paganism. How does this relate to the author’s own relationship to nature as described in chapter 15, “Three Nights at the Castle”?

5. Morpheus built Stone City with her own hands. Could you survive off the grid? How would you be affected by an intensely unplugged existence?

6. While televangelists broadcast to global audiences, Wicca and other Pagan traditions are mostly practiced in the shadows. How does secrecy affect the belief system? Would you be comfortable worshiping “underground”?

7. Which of the book’s many symbols was most powerful for you? What are your beliefs about the power of rituals?

8. Initiation rituals appear in various places throughout the book. What role has the concept of initiation played in either your religious or your secular life?

9. When the author goes into training with Karina, who struggles with earthly poverty, what does she learn from her mentor besides the practice of witchcraft?

10. At one gathering, the author meets a group of Dianic Wiccans of an all-female strain that emerged as part of second-wave feminism. But many Pagan traditions attract both men and women. Before reading the book, did you think of witchcraft as exclusively for women? What does the Pagan movement offer men in equal measure to what it offers women?

11. Before you read the book, what was your definition of magic? Did the practices in the book—whether those of Morpheus, Karina, or Josh—change your view of magic? Do you believe that a spell is similar to a prayer?

12. In chapter 17, “Sympathy for the Necromancer,” do Jonathan’s practices, while probably upsetting to most readers, also raise questions about how we view death?

13. In the final chapter, what transformation did you recognize in the author? What do you think the message of the closing section is?

Praise for Witches of America

Witches of America is brave and sharp and tenaciously researched. I would never have described myself as someone ‘interested in witchcraft’—Alex Mar’s book left me feeling the fault had been mine.” —John Jeremiah Sullivan, author of Pulphead

“Written with a beguiling blend of heart and wit, Witches of America sustains its thrall with something that runs much deeper than intrigue or pageantry. With the depth and scope of her curiosity, Alex Mar compelled me to follow her driving questions—about meaning, faith, and longing for community and wonder—on a breathless, deepening, and constantly surprising quest.” —Leslie Jamison, author of The Empathy Exams

“Like the best immersive subcultural reporting, Witches of America has its proper share of erotic charge (daggers, velvet, ritual nudity) and comic flair (a neurotic New Yorker meets an inedible Black Mass wafer). But what Alex Mar has actually achieved is something altogether more haunting. This is an intellectually serious and sweetly vulnerable work about connection both on and off the grid, and our common aspiration to lead lives spellbound and spellbinding.” —Gideon Lewis-Kraus, author of A Sense of Direction

Witches of America could be seen as a Gulliverian journey through various oddball sects scattered from California to New England, all of which believe in salvation through Magic—but the book is so much more than that. This is a quest to come to terms with the Unknowable.” —Richard Price, author of Lush Life

“Whatever you thought about witches, be prepared to think again. In Witches of America, Alex Mar exposes what we fear most—our own power. To be a witch is to reimagine the world.” —Terry Tempest Williams, author of When Women Were Birds

Witches of America
Barnes and Noble



Alex Mar lives in New York City, her hometown. She has contributed to The Believer, the Oxford American, Elle, The New York Times Book Review, Slate, New York magazine, and other publications. Mar is also the director of the documentary feature film American Mystic. Witches of America is her first book.

Guide written by Amy Clements


Among the Witches: Alex Mar on Samhain, Horror Movies, and the Occult

What’s Your Poet Animal Quiz

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>